Glacier Bay vs. American Standard: What’s Best Toilet Brand?

When it comes to choosing the best toilet brand, there are a lot of factors to consider. But which one is right for you? Glacier Bay or American Standard?

Let’s take a closer look at each brand and see which one comes out on top.

american standard vs glacier bay

Comparing Glacier Bay with American Standard

Here are the major differences between the Glacier Bay and American standard toilets:

Brand Popularity

Glacier Bay is an American brand but its toilets are exclusively sold by Home Depot. As a result, there is little information about the brand online.

Also, Glacier Bay is not a large brand. It offers a limited selection of toilets and has a somewhat limited footprint. Hence Glacier Bay is not a popular brand compared with American Standard.

American Standard, on the other hand, offers a wide selection of toilets and other plumbing fixtures. It is also an American brand but the toilet is available across different marketplaces, which makes it a more popular brand than Glacier Bay.

Being popular means more people have used American Standard toilets and can give their reviews about the product. Reviews go a long way in influencing purchase decisions.

Since American Standard toilets have a far larger selection of toilets than Glacier Bay, you’re open to a whole lot of toilet options to choose from. You’ll always find one that suits your taste. If you need a more popular brand, opt-in for American Standard.

Build Material

Both toilet brands make their products with a variety of materials and it depends mostly on what you prefer when it comes to choosing one.

The Glacier Bay toilets are usually made of vitreous china or ceramic. The toilet surface is finished with Sanagloss, which makes the surface smooth and stain-resistant. The glossy surface also makes cleaning easier without the need for harsh cleaning chemicals.

If you need a toilet that is easy to clean with good stain resistance, any of the Glacier Bay toilets will serve you right.

American Standard toilets are made of enamel-coated porcelain and are coated using an EverClean finish. The finish helps in preventing the growth of bacteria. Although the toilet surfaces are not as stain-resistant as those of Glacier Bay toilets, the flushing power helps in keeping stains off.

Both toilet brands make a good choice as long as you observe proper toilet maintenance.


Everybody wants a reliable, durable, and long-lasting toilet and not a toilet they have to replace annually.

Luckily, both Glacier Bay and American Standard toilets top the game here. Based on the materials they are made of, both brands are known to be durable.

For instance, either porcelain or vitreous china can serve you for several years. They can also withstand pressure for a long time. Both of the brands are good if you need a durable toilet.

glacier bay toilet review

Cost Comparison

Both brands have a wide price difference between them.

Considering that Glacier Bay is less popular and has a somewhat limited footprint, you can expect the brand to offer cheaper toilets.

Most people love Glacier Bay toilets because of their low cost, especially people with a tight budget.

Glacier Bay offers budget-friendly toilet models as low as $90. This means that if you’re financially constrained, you’ll still find a toilet that suits your budget.

Generally, Glacier Bay toilets are considered affordable options for construction and/or renovations in either residential or commercial buildings.

American Standard toilets, on the other hand, cost more. You can get American Standard toilets at a cost between $150 to over $500, depending on your preferred model. The higher cost means that American Standard toilets undoubtedly give more value for your money.

Toilet Quality

Since Glacier Bay toilets have lower costs, it’s normal to expect the brand to equally have lower quality.

However, this is not the truth as there are several other toilets out there that are worse than Glacier Bay toilets. While Glacier Bay doesn’t top the list, it offers a decent level of quality.

For American Standard toilets, the level of quality is fairly higher.

Although there were records of complaints from some customers, the reviews based on quality are appreciable. The American Standard toilets top the list in terms of toilet quality.

Product Warranty

Having a product warranty should be one of the qualities of a reliable manufacturer. Luckily, both Glacier Bay and American Standard offer a warranty on their toilets.

This means that in the case of any fault, you can return your product to get it fixed or replaced.

Notwithstanding, Glacier Bay toilets seem to have better warranties. For instance, Glacier Bay offers a limited lifetime warranty on all its toilets in addition to high-quality customer service.

American Standard offers warranties with varying periods. Some American Standard toilets come with a year warranty while others have between 5 to 10 years warranty.

Most times, this warranty is valid only after the buyer registers the toilet online after purchase.

Flushing Technology

Both brands have an appreciable flushing power. However, these brands use different flushing technologies.

Glacier Bay toilets use an ample amount of water to flush and the toilet coating doesn’t give room for staining.

This toilet brand uses the flapper system, which opens to allow water to rush into the toilet bowl to flush the toilet.

American Standard toilets offer a more powerful and cleaning flush with its EVERCLEAN technology.

This brand features a flushometer valve that creates suction action using air pressure. The suction flushes waste off the toilet bowl.


Since American Standard offers a wider selection of toilets than Glacier Bay, it’s usual to expect American Standard to have toilets that are aesthetically appealing and awesome.

American Standard toilets are available in various colors and designs to choose from. However, this is not so with Glacier Bay due to its limited collections.

Comparing Glacier Bay N2428RB vs American Standard 2887218.020 Toilet

To further explain the differences between the Glacier Bay toilets and American Standard toilets, here is a comparison of both models.

Our top pick for Glacier Bay toilets: Glacier Bay #N2428RB

Our top pick for American Standard toilets: American Standard 2887218.020 Toilet 

 Glacier Bay #N2428RBAmerican Standard 2887218.020
Toilet Height16.5 inches16.5 inches
Materialvitreous chinaporcelain
Flush Capacity0.92GPF/1.28GPFSingle 1.28GPF
Warrantylimited lifetime warrantylimited five-year warranty
PriceUnder 150Under 750
Flush TechnologyHigh-efficiency flush powerPowerWash Rim and Siphon Jet
Flush TriggerFlush leverFlush button

American Standard 2887218.020

The American Standard 2887218.020 is one of the best toilets from the American Standard brand. It’s available in round, elongated, and compact-elongated shapes. You will always find the size that fits your bathroom sizes.

It’s a standard-height toilet with a floor-to-rim height of 16.5 inches. Short users will always find this toilet comfortable.

It comes with a dual flush system – 0.92GPF/1.28GPF for efficient gravity flushing.

The American Standard 2887218.020 will leave you with a neat toilet and also help you to conserve water.

Thanks to the PowerWash rim and Siphon jet tech. All of these combine together to enable the toilet to give a powerful flush.

This toilet also uses EVERCLEAN technology, which makes it easy to clean. Unlike the Glacier Bay #N2428RB, the American Standard 2887218.020 doesn’t come with a toilet seat. Also, it comes with a 5-year warranty.


  • It features a dual-flush system for water conservation.
  • It gives an efficient and powerful flush.
  • It features EVERCLEAN technology for fighting off stains.
  • It’s available in different styles and shapes.
  • It comes with a 5-years warranty


  • It doesn’t come with a toilet seat

Glacier Bay #N2428RB

Glacier Bay #N2428RB is a two-piece toilet and is available with only a single flush system, delivering a powerful 1.28 GPF. It comes with either an elongated or round bowl. You can choose any style that suits your taste.

This toilet model has a floor-to-rim height of 16.5 inches. This makes Glacier Bay toilet an option for those who want standard-height toilets.

This toilet is made of high-quality and durable vitreous china materials with high resistance to stains and abrasion.

Since Glacier Bay #N2428RB uses a toilet flapper, it is equipped with a flush lever instead of a flush button.

This means that you have less control over how much water the toilet uses for flushing.

More so, just like most other toilets from Home Depot, this toilet model comes with a free wax ring, toilet T bolts, and a toilet seat that closes silently.

Glacier Bay #N2428RB comes with a limited lifetime warranty, which means that there is no harm in trying out the toilet. If you encounter any fault, you can easily get back to the company.


  • It features a QuickConnect system, which makes it easy to install.
  • It’s more affordable.
  • It comes with a toilet seat, wax ring, and toilet T bolts.
  • It is stain-resistant and easy to clean.
  • It uses an ample amount of water for flushing.


  • Flush performance issues may occur over time.
  • The toilet seat comes with plastic bolts, which may be flimsy.

Bottom Line

From the comparison above, it’s quite obvious that American Standard toilets are better than Glacier Bay toilets.

This is not to say that Glacier Bay toilets are bad. No! Glacier Bay toilets are good but American Standard toilets offer more in terms of quality, flushing technology, warranties, and aesthetics.

If you can afford an American Standard toilet, then go for it. But if you’re on a budget, Glacier Bay is still a good option.

Leave a Comment

error: Content is protected !!